If your partner proposed without an engagement ring, you might be feeling a whirlwind of emotions: excitement, joy, maybe a little surprise, and perhaps some uncertainty about what comes next. First, take a breath. You just said yes to the person you love, and that’s what truly matters.

The good news? You’re far from alone in this experience, and many couples find that shopping for a ring together turns out to be one of the most meaningful parts of their engagement journey. According to The Knot 2024 Jewelry & Engagement Study, which surveyed over 7,000 recently engaged couples, 77% of proposees had some involvement in selecting their engagement ring, with 29% shopping alongside their partner. What once might have seemed unconventional has become the new normal, and for many couples, it’s made the experience even more special.

Whether your partner proposed without a ring because they wanted you to choose something you’ll love forever, because the moment felt right and they couldn’t wait, or because they wanted to make this decision together, you’re now in the position to create your perfect ring experience as a team.

Why Proposals Without Rings Are More Common Than You Think

The image of a surprise proposal with a sparkling ring hidden in a velvet box is deeply embedded in our cultural imagination. But the reality of modern engagements looks quite different. We find that many couples now jointly shop for their engagement rings. This shift reflects a broader cultural change toward collaborative decision-making in relationships.

There are countless reasons why someone might propose without a ring, and nearly all of them come from a thoughtful, loving place:

• They want you to love what you wear every day. Your partner may recognize that you have particular taste in jewelry, and rather than guess and potentially miss the mark, they want you to choose something that feels perfectly you.
• The moment felt right. Sometimes love doesn’t wait for perfect logistics. Your partner may have been so moved in a particular moment that they couldn’t hold back the question any longer.
• They believe this should be a shared decision. Marriage is a partnership, and choosing a ring together can be a beautiful first step in making decisions as a team.
• Budget considerations. Perhaps they want to save together for something special, or they want to make sure you’re both comfortable with the investment.
• Custom design plans. If your partner has ideas about creating something completely unique, or wants to incorporate family stones, shopping together makes practical sense.

Real Couples Who Loved Their Ring-Free Proposals

If you’re wondering how other couples have navigated this experience, you’ll find that many embraced the opportunity with open arms, and often discovered unexpected joy in the process.

One woman whose husband proposed during a home renovation project shared on WeddingWire that he proposed with a piece of copper piping he cut from their new plumbing, painting the inside with nail polish so her finger wouldn’t turn green. They picked out a ring together afterward, and that copper ring became a cherished keepsake.

One couple on WeddingBee got engaged during a hike: “We were on a hike by a beautiful stream and the light was dappled through the trees… I told him ‘this would be a good place to propose.’ But I meant, like, at some point in the not so distant future because that was a spot we went to regularly. He knelt down right then and there! When people asked to see the ring, I told them we don’t have one yet and nobody gasped or anything. After a couple months, we went and picked one out together.”

Photo byTimo Stern onUnsplash

Understanding Your Feelings

Even though proposals without rings are increasingly common, you may still have mixed emotions, and that’s completely normal. If you’re feeling any disappointment alongside your excitement, it helps to identify the source of those feelings so you can address them thoughtfully.

Ask yourself:

• Is it about the surprise? Many of us grow up imagining a particular kind of proposal moment. If you’re mourning the surprise element, remember that your partner can still surprise you with a “re-proposal” once you’ve chosen the ring together, or with the timing and setting of when they give you the final ring.
• Is it about what others will think? The first question people often ask after “You’re engaged?!” is “Let me see the ring!” It can feel awkward to explain that you don’t have one yet. But here’s the truth: anyone who truly cares about you will be thrilled about your engagement regardless of whether you’re wearing a ring at that moment.
• Is it about the commitment? Occasionally, a ring-free proposal might raise questions about your partner’s level of commitment. If this is weighing on you, have an honest conversation. In most cases, you’ll find that the lack of a ring has nothing to do with their certainty about wanting to marry you.
• Is it about not feeling “officially” engaged? Engagement is defined by your mutual decision to marry, not by a piece of jewelry. As one bride put it on WeddingWire: “My grandparents were married 25 years before Grandpa was able to get a diamond ring for Grandma. An engagement does not require an engagement ring.”

Having the Conversation

Once you’ve identified your feelings, share them with your partner. Even couples who communicate beautifully can sometimes miss signals about expectations. Approach this conversation from a place of love and partnership.

Start by expressing your excitement about your engagement and your love for your partner. Then, share what’s on your mind, whether that’s your eagerness to pick out a ring together, questions about the timeline, or any feelings you’re processing. Listen to their perspective too. You might discover they have thoughtful plans already in motion, or they may be excited to hear your ideas about what you want.

Some questions to discuss together:

• Do we want to go ring shopping together, or would you prefer to choose and surprise me?
• What’s our budget for the ring?
• Are there any styles, diamond shapes, or metals I’ve mentioned before that you remember?
• When would we like to go ring shopping?
• Do we want to share our engagement news now, or wait until we have the ring?

Making Ring Shopping a Memorable Experience

One of the beautiful things about choosing a ring together is that you can turn it into its own special memory. This isn’t just running an errand; it’s celebrating your commitment to each other.

Ideas for making your ring shopping day special:

• Start with brunch or coffee at a meaningful spot. Maybe where you had your first date, or a favorite neighborhood café.
• Plan a champagne toast afterward. Whether you find the ring or not that day, celebrate the experience together.
• Take photos. Capture the moment when you try on rings, especially when you find “the one.”
• Make a weekend of it. If you’re visiting a showroom in a different city, turn it into a mini getaway.
• Include loved ones if you’d like. Some couples invite a close friend or family member to share in the experience.

At our showrooms, we’ve designed spaces specifically to make this experience enjoyable and pressure-free. Our VIP diamond viewing rooms allow couples to explore diamonds together in ideal lighting, taking their time to compare stones and make decisions at their own pace. We recognize that jewelry shopping has evolved, and that couples increasingly want to share this experience together. 

Exploring Styles Together

If you don’t already know exactly what you want, ring shopping together gives you the chance to discover your preferences as a couple. You might be surprised by what catches your eye once you see options in person.

Classic Solitaire	Halo	Three Stone
A single center diamond on a simple band. Timeless, elegant, and lets the diamond take center stage.	Smaller diamonds surround the center stone, creating extra brilliance and making the center appear larger.	A center diamond flanked by two side stones, often representing past, present, and future.

Vintage	Hidden Halo	Side Stone
Intricate details like milgrain, filigree, and engraving inspired by different eras.	A ring of smaller diamonds sits beneath the center stone, visible from the side profile.	Additional diamonds along the band add sparkle and dimension to the ring.

This is just the beginning. Our engagement ring style guide explores even more options, and our jewelry consultants are always happy to show you variations you might not have considered.

Diamond Shapes to Consider

Beyond the setting style, the shape of your center diamond dramatically affects the overall look of your ring. Here’s a quick overview:

• Round brilliant: The most popular shape, known for exceptional sparkle and versatility.
• Oval: Elongated and elegant, ovals can make fingers appear longer and often look larger than round diamonds of the same carat weight.
• Cushion: Soft, rounded corners give this shape a romantic, vintage feel.
• Emerald: A step-cut diamond with a rectangular shape and elegant, mirrored facets.
• Pear: Combining round and marquise shapes, the teardrop silhouette is distinctive and feminine.
• Marquise: An elongated shape with pointed ends that maximizes carat weight.
• Radiant: A rectangular shape with trimmed corners and brilliant-cut faceting for maximum sparkle.
• Princess: A square shape with brilliant faceting, modern and eye-catching.

Lab-Grown or Natural: Deciding Together

One advantage of shopping together is the opportunity to discuss whether a lab-grown diamond or natural diamond feels right for your relationship.

Both options are chemically and optically identical diamonds. The difference lies in their origin and what matters most to you as a couple. Some prioritize the rarity and heritage of natural diamonds. Others appreciate that lab-grown diamonds often allow for a larger stone within the same budget. There’s no wrong choice here, only what feels right for you.

Our jewelry consultants are happy to show you both options side by side and answer any questions you have. We present clear information so you can make a confident decision together.

Metals and Personal Style

The metal you choose affects both the look and longevity of your ring. Here’s what to consider:

• White gold: A classic choice with a bright, silvery appearance that complements any diamond beautifully.
• Yellow gold: Warm and traditional, yellow gold has made a major comeback in recent years. It pairs beautifully with vintage styles and warmer skin tones.
• Rose gold: Romantic and distinctive, with a warm pink hue that’s become increasingly popular.
• Platinum: The most durable precious metal, naturally white, and hypoallergenic.
• Two-tone: Combining metals, like yellow gold and white gold, for a unique look.

Look at the jewelry you already wear. Do you gravitate toward silver, gold, or a mix? Your existing collection can guide your decision.

What to Expect When You Visit

Walking into a jewelry showroom as a couple should feel exciting, not intimidating. Here’s what to expect when you visit one of our locations:

• No pressure. We guide rather than pressure. Your jewelry consultant is there to educate and support you, not to push you toward any particular purchase.
• Time to explore. Try on as many rings as you’d like. See how different shapes, settings, and metals look on your hand.
• Expert guidance. Our team has over a century of collective experience. We can explain the four Cs, help you understand value, and answer any questions.
• VIP treatment. Our private diamond viewing rooms let you examine stones in ideal lighting, without feeling rushed or observed.
• Inclusive approach. We celebrate love.
• Rigorous diamond standards: Only 1 in 10 diamonds meets our quality criteria. Every stone is hand-selected for exceptional cut, clarity, color, and carat weight.
• Expert designers: Our designer boutiques feature collections from renowned names like Tacori, Verragio, and A.JAFFE.

While walk-ins are always welcome, you can also book an appointment to ensure dedicated time with one of our jewelry consultants.

The Robbins Brothers Difference

For more than 100 years, we’ve been guiding couples through one of life’s most meaningful purchases. What sets us apart is our approach: we’ve always been a neighborhood jeweler at heart, focused on building genuine relationships rather than making sales.

Whether you’re visiting our flagship in Pasadena or any of our locations across Arizona, California, Texas, and Washington, you’ll experience the same commitment to exceptional service and craftsmanship.

Announcing Your Engagement

Some couples wonder whether they should share their engagement news before they have a ring. The answer is entirely up to you. Some prefer to wait until they have a ring to show, while others are too excited to keep the news quiet, ring or not.

If you share your news before you have a ring, you’ll likely encounter some curious questions. A simple response like “We’re choosing the ring together!” typically satisfies people’s curiosity. Most people will be genuinely excited for you regardless.

If you prefer to have something on your finger while you shop, consider a simple placeholder band or even a fun costume ring. Some couples use this as an opportunity for an inside joke or meaningful temporary symbol.

After You Find the Ring

Once you’ve found or designed your perfect ring, you might choose to have a special moment when your partner officially puts it on your finger. Some couples have a “re-proposal” at a meaningful location. Others simply enjoy a quiet, intimate moment when the ring is ready.

Don’t forget to:

• Get it insured. Protect your investment with jewelry insurance.
• Learn proper care. We’ll teach you how to keep your ring sparkling.
• Start thinking about wedding bands. Browse women’s wedding bands and men’s wedding bands to find styles that complement your engagement ring.

Browse a few of our engagement ring styles online, then stop in to your local Robbins Brothers or make an appointment and we’ll help create a beautiful and romantic day that you’ll cherish forever.

[starbox]